PDA

View Full Version : New Book calls Nagin a clueless,collapsing coward



Stormlover
05-04-2006, 09:45 AM
When Nagin lost it

New book calls him a coward

BY HELEN KENNEDY
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER

A new book about the Katrina catastrophe paints a portrait of New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin as a clueless, collapsing coward who hid out after the hurricane in a high-rise hotel - and had to be rousted out of Air Force One's bathroom.
While Tulane University historian Douglas Brinkley is generous with his entertainingly unflattering descriptions, he reserves his greatest disdain for Nagin and largely praises Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco, who cooperated with the author.

Nagin brushed off the book, but told The Times-Picayune of New Orleans that no "credible" historian would publish such "a political hit" just days before the Big Easy's May 20 mayoral runoff election. Several of the most damning anecdotes are sourced to an aide who is now running against Nagin.

In excerpts published yesterday in Vanity Fair, Brinkley describes Nagin as spending most of the week after the storm holed up on the 27th floor of the Hyatt Hotel, looking down on the misery of the Superdome.

With all power out, visitors had to climb the stairs if they wanted to talk with him. Brinkley also describes the mayor scurrying to the roof when a cop warned that rabble-rousers were leading a mob to the hotel from the Superdome.

The book contains at least two scenes in which Nagin is described as hiding in bathrooms. One came after his famously emotional call to a local radio station, when he gave voice to the city's rage by demanding federal officials "get off your asses."

Nagin broke down crying after the call and spent 20 minutes in the bathroom "rearranging knickknacks and toiletries," Brinkley recounts.

In another, Nagin boards Air Force One for a meeting with President Bush and Blanco and is offered a shower while waiting for Bush.

"Like a teenager, Nagin just wouldn't get out of the bathroom," Brinkley writes, saying the mayor wanted to shave his head for a photo op. Aides tried to hurry him, and finally a Secret Service agent kicked the door and ordered him out, Brinkley says.

Nagin also is attacked for leaving New Orleans for Dallas a week after the storm. New Orleans police even put up mocking signs at the department's makeshift headquarters.

Originally published on May 4, 2006

eyendastorm
05-04-2006, 10:22 AM
Even though I don't care for the guy anymore...I still say it was Blanco who dragged her feet through all this. It's a fact that when Nagin was begging for help, Pres Bush asked Blanco if she wanted the State taken over....She asked for 48 hours (or 72, can't remember???) TO THINK ABOUT IT!.
I almost didn't post cause I really don't want to start the big ole debate of "whos at fault"...but, I still do believe that Blanco had the powers, NOT Nagin, to get help to the city faster than what was done. Now, if you wanta fault Nagin for something...that'll prolly be what happened BEFORE the storm. But again, I still have trouble with blaming the Mayor that people didn't leave when they were told to. But, that's just my opinion!

Stormlover
05-04-2006, 10:31 AM
Even though I don't care for the guy anymore...I still say it was Blanco who dragged her feet through all this. It's a fact that when Nagin was begging for help, Pres Bush asked Blanco if she wanted the State taken over....She asked for 48 hours (or 72, can't remember???) TO THINK ABOUT IT!.
I almost didn't post cause I really don't want to start the big ole debate of "whos at fault"...but, I still do believe that Blanco had the powers, NOT Nagin, to get help to the city faster than what was done. Now, if you wanta fault Nagin for something...that'll prolly be what happened BEFORE the storm. But again, I still have trouble with blaming the Mayor that people didn't leave when they were told to. But, that's just my opinion!
He waited WAY too late to tell them to leave and then provided no way for many of them to leave.I don't want to get into all of this again,and I agree with you that Blanco deserved alot of the blame too...

Hemorhage
05-04-2006, 10:37 AM
Even though I don't care for the guy anymore...I still say it was Blanco who dragged her feet through all this. It's a fact that when Nagin was begging for help, Pres Bush asked Blanco if she wanted the State taken over....She asked for 48 hours (or 72, can't remember???) TO THINK ABOUT IT!.
I almost didn't post cause I really don't want to start the big ole debate of "whos at fault"...but, I still do believe that Blanco had the powers, NOT Nagin, to get help to the city faster than what was done. Now, if you wanta fault Nagin for something...that'll prolly be what happened BEFORE the storm. But again, I still have trouble with blaming the Mayor that people didn't leave when they were told to. But, that's just my opinion!

Yeah, for she does have the power to over-ride any Mayor or any Official in the State!

Stormlover
05-04-2006, 10:47 AM
Yeah, for she does have the power to over-ride any Mayor or any Official in the State!
On some things,but we have a system of government,that is why Bush was ASKING the governor to let the Federal Government take over,the governor can't just take over a city against the mayors and his police departments wishes just like that.

eyendastorm
05-04-2006, 10:53 AM
He waited WAY too late to tell them to leave and then provided no way for many of them to leave.I don't want to get into all of this again,and I agree with you that Blanco deserved alot of the blame too...

But, cha know Storm...here we go again. Do YOU need someone to tell you to leave when you've got a hurricane headed your way? We've done this all our lives....I sure don't!
But, no debate here. People screwed up. Lots of people....but, I really believe that the people who 'chose' to stay should be blamed also!!! Not the sick...not the elderly, but people that COULD HAVE hopped on a bus and took off.

Hemorhage
05-04-2006, 10:54 AM
But, cha know Storm...here we go again. Do YOU need someone to tell you to leave when you've got a hurricane headed your way? We've done this all our lives....I sure don't!
But, no debate here. People screwed up. Lots of people....but, I really believe that the people who 'chose' to stay should be blamed also!!! Not the sick...not the elderly, but people that COULD HAVE hopped on a bus and took off.


Can I get an "Amen"?